BRUSSELS: In a setback for Western efforts to tighten sanctions against Iran, a top EU court Friday threw out penalties imposed on several Iranian businesses for their alleged ties to the country’s disputed nuclear program.
The ruling by the EU’s general court in Luxembourg coincided with an announcement by the EU’s top diplomat that she would meet with Tehran’s new negotiator in the hope of fostering better ties and breaking a stalemate over what the West says is a quest for atomic weapons. The EU court ruled there wasn’t sufficient evidence to justify the sanctions imposed by the 28-nation bloc on eight Iranian banks and companies.
The court said the sanctions would stay in place for at least two months pending any appeal. If an appeal is filed by an EU government, the sanctions would remain binding until a ruling.
Friday’s ruling affects private and semigovernmental banks with mostly domestic activities, an insurance company covering Iranian international trade, and engineering firms known for their oil business, the main source of Iran’s foreign revenue.
“We are fully aware, as are the [EU] member states, of the consequences deriving from these judgments,” said Michael Mann, spokesman for EU foreign policy chief Catherine Ashton.
He said Ashton’s office “and the EU’s member states are also fully aware of the need to come to a swift conclusion on the approach regarding these cases,” underscoring the importance of the ruling.
The EU is one of Iran’s most important trading partners. But since 2010, the bloc has imposed asset freezes and travel bans on top of existing U.N. sanctions, targeting Iranian citizens and firms believed to be linked to the country’s nuclear program. The EU then significantly escalated the nuclear-related sanctions by 2012 to include an oil-import embargo.
Despite the West’s claims, Tehran insists its nuclear program is for civilian purposes. Years of negotiations with Iran by the five permanent U.N. Security Council members plus Germany have failed to make much headway.
Still, Friday’s ruling came amid what appears to be the start of a thaw in the protracted process: Iran’s new President Hassan Rouhani confirmed Thursday that Foreign Minister Javad Zarif – a Western-educated diplomat – will lead nuclear talks with world powers, marking a shift away from the often more hawkish security officials who had previously set the negotiation strategy.
At a meeting of the EU’s 28 foreign ministers in Vilnius, Lithuania Friday, Ashton said she called Zarif and agreed to meet with him later this month on the sidelines of the U.N. General Assembly. “I stand ready with my colleagues to get the talks moving,” she said.
Ashton added that she hoped “that when we meet in New York we will have the opportunity to set dates [for the formal talks] there.”
“We’ve got some good proposals on the table. We are always willing to listen to good proposals from Iran. We really want to move now quickly to resolve this,” Ashton said.
While it is assumed Iran’s Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei will have the last word on the nuclear issue, Rouhani was elected on the promise of getting rid of the international sanctions that are crippling Iran’s economy. Analysts view the appointment of the Foreign Affairs Ministry to lead the nuclear negotiations – instead of the Supreme National Security Council – as a sign the new administration might be more willing to compromise with the West.
A report by the semi-official Mehr news agency in Iran Friday pointed in the same direction. It quoted Zarif as saying Iran sees an “interest” in removing misunderstandings through “constructive talks.”
Foreign Minister Carl Bildt of Sweden said in Vilnius that he sees a broader shift in approach as other leading Iranian officials had also been named to new posts linked to the nuclear issue. “They all point in the same direction,” Bildt said. “That they are more interested in a dialogue.”
Friday’s EU court ruling voided the freezing of assets held in the EU by Post Bank Iran, Iran Insurance Company, Good Luck Shipping and Export Development Bank of Iran. It found that the bloc’s governments couldn’t “properly establish that they had provided support for nuclear proliferation.”
The court also annulled the sanctions imposed on Bank Refah Kargaran, Persia International Bank, a businessman identified only as Mr. Bateni, and Iranian Offshore Engineering & Construction Co., citing insufficient evidence.
But the court dismissed a similar lawsuit brought forward by the country’s important Bank Melli Iran because the institute continued to pay scholarships for the Atomic Energy Organization of Iran after the latter was put on a U.N. Security Council sanctions list.
The court also upheld sanctions against the Germany-based EIHB, or European-Iranian trade bank, leaving its funds frozen.