Mobile  |  About us  |  Photos  |  Videos  |  Subscriptions  |  RSS Feeds  |  Today's Paper  |  Classifieds  |  Contact Us
Advanced Search
The Daily Star
THURSDAY, 23 MAY 2013
01:51 PM Beirut time
Weather    
Beirut
25 °C
Blom Index
BLOM
1,210down
Film
Follow this story Print Email this RSS Feed ePaper share this
Oscar-nominee 'Five Broken Cameras' sparks identity debate
Agence France Presse
A poster for the Oscar-nominated documentary "5 Broken Cameras" is displayed at a theatre in the West Bank city of Ramallah in this January 28, 2013 file photo. REUTERS/Mohamad Torokman/Files
A poster for the Oscar-nominated documentary "5 Broken Cameras" is displayed at a theatre in the West Bank city of Ramallah in this January 28, 2013 file photo. REUTERS/Mohamad Torokman/Files
A+ A-

JERUSALEM: "Five Broken Cameras" the Oscar-nominated documentary about Palestinian popular resistance in the occupied West Bank, has found itself at the centre of an unusual debate -- over its identity.

Co-directed by Palestinian Emad Burnat and Israeli Guy Davidi, the film documents the story of Bil'in village and the struggle of its residents to protect their land from Jewish settlers and Israel's giant separation barrier.

But while the story is Palestinian throughout, the film was made with funding from the Jewish state.

The story follows the villagers' weekly demonstrations against the seizure of their land through the eyes of Burnat's family.

When the Oscar nominations were announced in January, two local films got the nod, which some immediately pounced upon as a runaway Israeli success.

One was "The Gatekeepers," which offers a glimpse into the secret world of Israel's Shin Bet domestic security agency through the eyes of six of its former chiefs.

The other was "Five Broken Cameras."

"Two Israeli films are among the five nominated for best documentary for the Academy Awards," Israel's embassy in the United States said on its Twitter feed immediately after the nominations were announced.

It was a narrative quickly echoed by some of the Israeli press.

"After a remarkable string of Oscar nominations for scripted dramas, Israel's film industry has managed a new feat in 2013: earning two nods in a different category, in a single year," said the online Times of Israel.

The Jerusalem Post also flagged it as an achievement for "Israeli cinema."

For Burnat, it was a "cunning attempt" to damage the film.

"The Israeli press tried to describe the film as Israeli which was strange to me because it is about me, my family and my village," he told AFP.

"It cannot be an Israeli movie because it is about an attempt to erase Palestine."

For Burnat's co-director Davidi, the debate about whether the film is Israeli or Palestinian is "not important."

"For me, the whole discussion is not a very important one because for me generally, films do not represent countries, even if they are produced by countries," he told AFP.

"I don't think films should have nationalities."

The film, which also received French funding, tracks the life of Burnat and his family since the birth of their son Jibril in 2005, the same year Israel began building its sprawling separation barrier on lands owned by the village.

The title comes from the five cameras that were broken as Burnat captured the villagers' plight on film over the years.

Davidi, a former Israeli activist who used to attend the weekly solidarity protests, got involved at Burnat's request to help with production problems.

"I asked Guy to come and take part in the movie because he was a solidarity activist who comes to the demonstrations with us. I didn't ask him to come to represent Israel or take part in an Israeli-Palestinian production," Burnat said.

"Guy doesn't represent Israel; he helped with the production and the funding."

Davidi says there are many Israelis who produce work critical of the occupation, which often gives official Israel a way of showcasing the country's democratic principles.

"There is an expectation that Israeli filmmakers will represent their country... but there is a way to use them to show Israel is democratic and an open society that allows open discussion and freedom of speech," he explains.

"I am not willing to be used in that way to clear Israel's name, especially as I am a part of a very small minority," he said.

Much of the media wanted to put the focus on "the beautiful Israeli who supports the Palestinians" in a narrative rejected by both directors, Davidi said.

"Neither of us weren't willing to put a lot of emphasis on that because the important thing in our story is to finish the occupation and change reality and not to beautify relations and make the audience think there is hope."

Despite isolated attempts to co-opt the film, official Israel has not got involved, except for providing some of the funding through the ministry of culture and sport.

A spokesman told AFP the ministry was not responsible for the selection of films but allocated money on the basis of criteria recommended by the Israeli Film Council.

Even if the documentary does win an Academy Award at Sunday's ceremony, Davidi can't see the government embracing the film.

"I'm sure that if it wins the Oscar, the film will not be adopted, although in many cases I wish they would," he said, indicating it could be used to great effect within the educational system.

"If Israeli officials actually took the film in order to do truthful self-accounting that helped with education, like showing the film in the parliament or inviting people in Israel to see it, this would be a positive thing."

 
Home Film
 
     
 
Palestine
Advertisement
Around the Web
Comments  

Your feedback is important to us!

We invite all our readers to share with us their views and comments about this article.

Disclaimer: Comments submitted by third parties on this site are the sole responsibility of the individual(s) whose content is submitted. The Daily Star accepts no responsibility for the content of comment(s), including, without limitation, any error, omission or inaccuracy therein. Please note that your email address will NOT appear on the site.

comments powered by Disqus
Story Summary
"Five Broken Cameras" the Oscar-nominated documentary about Palestinian popular resistance in the occupied West Bank, has found itself at the centre of an unusual debate -- over its identity.

Co-directed by Palestinian Emad Burnat and Israeli Guy Davidi, the film documents the story of Bil'in village and the struggle of its residents to protect their land from Jewish settlers and Israel's giant separation barrier.

But while the story is Palestinian throughout, the film was made with funding from the Jewish state.

When the Oscar nominations were announced in January, two local films got the nod, which some immediately pounced upon as a runaway Israeli success.

For Burnat, it was a "cunning attempt" to damage the film.

For Burnat's co-director Davidi, the debate about whether the film is Israeli or Palestinian is "not important".

Even if the documentary does win an Academy Award at Sunday's ceremony, Davidi can't see the government embracing the film.
Related Articles
 
 
Lebanese film banned over Israel footage
 
 
Israel seeks to end Palestinian prisoner's hunger strike
 
 
Israel clears jailers in Australian prisoner death
High hopes for Palestinian 3D animated 'Scarecrow' film
 
 
Israel willing to deport Palestinian on hunger strike
Show More
Entities
Advertisement
Most Popular
Viewed Searched e-mailed
1. Burial of Hezbollah fighter sparks tension in Sidon
 
2. General says Israel ready to attack Syria should Assad fall
 
3. Lebanese city in flames, truce proves elusive
 
4. Southern suburbs receive dead from Qusair
 
5. Fierce n. Lebanon clashes kill two, wound more
 
6. Syrian rebels stay out of Tripoli fight
Advertisement
Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Linked In Follow us on Google+ Subscribe to our Live Feed
Multimedia
Images  
Pictures of the day
A selection of images from around the world- Wednesday May 22, 2013
View all view all
Advertisement
Rami G. Khouri
Rami G. Khouri
A Hezbollah turning point in Qusair?
Michael Young
Michael Young
March 14 drifts away from the state
David Ignatius
David Ignatius
A struggle for positions precedes the Geneva conference
View all view all
Advertisement
cartoon
 
Click to View Articles
 
 
News
Business
Opinion
Sports
Culture
Technology
Entertainment
Privacy Policy | Anti-Spamming Policy | Disclaimer | Copyright Notice
© 2013 The Daily Star - All Rights Reserved - Designed and Developed By IDS