Mobile  |  About us  |  Photos  |  Videos  |  Subscriptions  |  RSS Feeds  |  Today's Paper  |  Classifieds  |  Contact Us
The Daily Star
FRIDAY, 25 MAY 2012
03:29 PM Beirut time
Weather    
Beirut
25 °C
Blom Index
1,164.8down
A+ A-
     
 
Advanced Search
Local News  
History curriculum revision sparks controversy

BEIRUT: On April 26, 2005, the last soldier of a roughly 30,000-strong Syrian force withdrew from Lebanese territories days after at least a million people from across the country rallied in Beirut, demanding, among other things, the complete withdrawal of the Syrian army from Lebanon.The withdrawal was preceded by a series of rallies against the Syrian presence in Lebanon, protests that culminated on March 14, 2005. The demonstrations, initially called the Independence Intifada, and later the Beirut Spring, were referred to by a U.S. State Department official as the “Cedar Revolution,” a name which quickly caught on in Lebanon and around the world.

But a ministerial committee recently decided to scrap the phrase “Cedar Revolution” from a national middle school history curriculum currently being developed, and decided instead to describe the event as a “wave of demonstrations,” eliciting anger from the country’s politicians who took part in the rallies against the foreign army’s presence in Lebanon.

Metn MP Sami Gemayel told The Daily Star Monday that it is a dangerous act to remove key phases from the country’s history. “The Cedar Revolution of 2005 resulted in Lebanon’s second independence,” said Gemayel.

In recent months, many political commentators and officials have also said that the so-called “Arab Spring,” which has now witnessed the overthrow of four Arab regimes, was a inspired by the democratic changes that occurred in Lebanon in the midst of the Cedar Revolution.

According to Gemayel, the Lebanese history curriculum should include all events that took place in the country, without any exception.

But one of the ministerial committee’s members, Culture Minister Gaby Layyoun, said that “Cedar Revolution” is a phrase fabricated by the U.S. and its “Assistant Secretary of State for Near Eastern Affairs Jeffrey Feltman.”

The name was actually coined during a news conference by another U.S. official, Under Secretary of State for Global Affairs Paula J. Dobriansky.

“We cannot keep such a phrase in the curriculum ... [It] is sensitive to many in the country and it might create problems between people,” said Layyoun.

Layyoun said that he is not against mentioning the demonstrations of March 2005 in the new middle school history curriculum that is being developed by the committee. But he said: “I personally took part in the demonstrations that led to the withdrawal of Syrian troops from Lebanon ... this was not the Cedar Revolution ... only some people are trying to portray it that way.”

Responding to Layyoun, Gemayel asked whether it would be reasonable to scrap Liberation Day, which marks the withdrawal of Israeli troops from south Lebanon in 2000. “I don’t think we have the right to remove Hezbollah’s liberation of south Lebanon from the history curriculum,” said Gemayel.

“Such a curriculum should be studied by officials and historians from all sides, not by a one-sided government.”

Progressive Socialist Party leader MP Walid Jumblatt also criticized those who refuse to recognize the Cedar Revolution of 2005.

“Is it possible to deny historical facts and bright pages from Lebanese modern history as Culture Minister Gaby Layyoun did by refusing to recognize the Cedar Revolution?” he asked.

“Does disagreement in politics erase historical events?” said Jumblatt in a column to be published Tuesday in the PSP’s weekly newspaper Al-Anbaa.

Meanwhile, several historians said Tuesday that if a unified Lebanese history textbook is to be written, it should be written in full because history requires all that has ever happened to be recorded.

Toni Nissi, the head of the International Council for the Cedar Revolution, said the ministerial committee’s actions are just one of several attempts to rewrite history in the interest of the Syrian and Iranian regimes.

“One of the achievements of the [pro-Syria groups] is that they set a history curriculum by force after the Taif Accord,” said Nissi.

But Nissi says that the Cedar Revolution is not over and it is an ongoing struggle for reform to make the state strong and sovereign.

“The current government is trying through the use of arms to return Lebanon to the period prior to the withdrawal of Syrian troops,” Nissi added.

Issam Khalifeh, professor of history at the Lebanese University said that a discussion of the development of a new history curriculum is not currently possible.

“It is not possible to agree on a unified curriculum or a unified book since the war in Lebanon is not really over yet ... you still have armed factions throughout the country,” said Khalifeh.

Khalifeh says that efforts to develop a unified history curriculum would fail as long as there is still a danger of civil strife in Lebanon.

“Let us first get over with the history of the Civil War ... let us write how much it cost us in money, deaths, injuries, displaced.”

Meanwhile on social networking websites, Lebanese voiced their own points of view on the country’s recent history.

“It is part of our history, it is a fact. We can’t deny something that has happened, we need to put it in our history books,” Fady Adhamy said in a comment on Facebook in response to The Daily Star’s poll on whether the Cedar Revolution should be taught at schools.

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Daily Star on January 31, 2012, on page 1.
Home Local News
 
 
Cedars Revolution / Syria / Hezbollah / History / Lebanon
Advertisement
Comments  
Mowaten Libnèni January 31, 2012 04:19 AM

Second independence? Gemayel's clearly forgotten that Israel's presence was ALSO an occupation in southern Lebanon.

It's about time all Lebanese schools have a unified history book and not different versions of different events -- though it would be ok for them to gloss over sensitive things that took place in the civil war, for example.

George January 31, 2012 07:05 AM

The whole purpose of writing the history of any nation is to demonstrate the facts of the period as they happened.

History should not be tweaked in any way, shape, or form to conform to the dictates of any group or outside force, whoever they may be.

Joseph January 31, 2012 11:55 PM

2005 - is a Cedar Revolution, a Gucci Revolution.

Call it whatever you want, it was a civil revolution by a people that has much experience, and that handled it well -- with self-restraint and wisdom.

The Objective was clear and it was achieved.

Paul February 01, 2012 03:21 PM

Now we need a Beirut Revolution to get rid of Hezbollah weapons, Iranians meddlers bel-jemleh and Syrian moukhabarat and gangs.

Your feedback is important to us!
We invite all our readers to share with us their views and comments about this article.

Disclaimer: Comments submitted by third parties on this site are the sole responsibility of the individual(s) whose content is submitted. The Daily Star accepts no responsibility for the content of comment(s), including, without limitation, any error, omission or inaccuracy therein. Please note that your email address will NOT appear on the site. All fields are mandatory.

Name *
Email *
Country *
City *
Comment
*
Word Count: Left:
Toolbox
print
email
e-paper
e-paper
Related
Hariri Meets Russian delegation
March 14: Time for Mikati to leave
To topple or not to topple?
Lebanese-Syrian hostage saga ends after ex-mayor’s mediation
Iran envoy: Assad’s reforms will herald change
Karam released from prison after serving 20 months for Israel ties
Antonine University tensions reach LU, scuffle breaks out
Central Bekaa protests against Syria steadily rise
Lebanese have obligation to support Assad’s fall: Feltman
Can Israel’s ‘Dome’ work against Hezbollah? - analysis
More from
Van Meguerditchian
Jacque Vergès: U.S. pressuring France on jailed Abdallah
Bkirki committee narrows down electoral law proposals
Civil society says proportional representation fair
Armenians mark genocide with march to Turkish Embassy
Armenian-Lebanese protest outside Turkish embassy
Armenia envoy: Denial as bad as genocide
Turkish cultural center opens its doors in Beirut
Tensions flare between LF, FPM students
Lack of phone-data access slows probe into attempt on Geagea
Karam released from prison after serving 20 months for Israel ties
View allview all
Advertisement
Most Popular
Viewed Searched e-mailed
1. Hazard to finally reveal new team after Belgium friendly
 
2. Lebanon's opposition calls on Mikati government to resign
 
3. Initial probe into killing of Lebanese sheikh nearing end
 
4. Say cheese! NASA Mars rover photographs own shadow
 
5. Hezbollah: 'March 14 weapons' should be directed at Israel
 
6. Assad aides were targets of assassination attempt, Israeli officials say: report
Advertisement
 
Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Linked In Follow us on Google+ Subscribe to our Live Feed
 
Multimedia
Images Video  
Pictures of the Day
A selection of images from around the world- Thursday May 24, 2012
View all view all
Rami G. Khouri
Rami G. Khouri
Egyptians as they really are, for once
Michael Young
Michael Young
Will Tripoli make Samir Geagea pay?
David Ignatius
David Ignatius
A string of detonators cuts through the Middle East
View all view all
 
cartoon
 
Click to View Articles
Advertisement
 
 
News
Business
Opinion
Sports
Culture
Technology
Entertainment
Privacy Policy | Anti-Spamming Policy | Disclaimer | Copyright Notice
© 2011 The Daily Star - All Rights Reserved - Designed and Developed By IDS