Middle East

Egypt top court says ruling nullifying parliament 'binding'

Egyptian President Mohammed Mursi. (AFP PHOTO/KHALED DESOUKI)

CAIRO: Egypt's Supreme Constitutional Court said on Monday that all of its rulings were "binding," in response to a presidential decree reinstating parliament after the court ruled the house invalid, Agence France Presses reported.

"All the rulings and decisions of the Supreme Constitutional Court are final and not subject to appeal... and are binding for all state institutions," the court said in a statement.

Several people have gone to court to challenge President Mohammed Mursi's decision ordering the return of parliament, and the Supreme Constitutional Court said it would look into these cases.

The court also stressed that it was "not a part of any political conflict... but the limit of its sacred duty is the protection of the texts of the constitution."

The Supreme Constitutional Court had said certain articles in the law governing parliamentary elections were invalid, annulling the Islamist-led house.

Reuters reported earlier Egypt's parliamentary speaker saying that the chamber would reconvene on Tuesday, risking a showdown with the army after the new, Islamist president defied the generals by quashing the dissolution of the legislature they had ordered last month.

Quoted by the state news agency on Monday, Saad al-Katatni, who like President Mohammed Mursi hails from the long-suppressed Muslim Brotherhood, said the lower house would sit from noon (1000 GMT) on Tuesday, overturning a court judgment and military order issued a month ago, before Mursi's election.

The move, heralded by a decree issued by Mursi on Sunday, barely a week after he took office, threatens Egypt with fresh political uncertainty likely to take a toll on a fragile economy and dash the hopes of many desperate for a period of calm after 17 turbulent months since the overthrow of Hosni Mubarak.

However, in a signal that relations have far from broken down between Mursi and the army, the president and the head of the military council appeared together, looking relaxed and in conversation, at a televised event on Monday morning.

The military council which had run Egypt since Mubarak was toppled by popular protests in February 2011 handed powers to Mursi on June 30, but it had sought to trim his authority shortly before he took office following a June 16-17 vote. It had dissolved parliament and taken legislative power for itself.

Yet in a move that seemed to take even the generals by surprise, Mursi said on Sunday he was recalling parliament and would hold an election once a constitution was in place, meaning the parliament would not serve a full four-year term.

The row is part of a broader power struggle which could take years to play out, pitting long suppressed Islamists against generals whose fellow officers ran Egypt for six decades and an establishment still packed with Mubarak-era officials.

But the immediate impact may be to make it more difficult for the president to stabilize an economy fast heading towards a balance of payments and budget crisis. The stock market reacted to Sunday's news by plunging more than 5 percent at the open.

"Early confrontation," wrote Al-Akhbar newspaper, summing up a decision which could end a brief honeymoon with the military council, led by Field Marshal Hussein Tantawi.

Yet Mursi and Tantawi showed no hint of discord on Monday when the president, as he did last week, attended a military parade. Seated next to each other, Mursi and Tantawi turned to each other in a brief jovial exchange, live television images showed.

And in a possible signal that the generals would not openly challenge Mursi, the state news agency reported that guards at parliament allowed some members back into the building after it had been declared off limits when the army ordered it dissolved.

Some analysts said Mursi's decision to order early elections could offer a compromise by acknowledging the court's assertion that the election to the chamber breached some legal rules.

But even if the army does not seek an open row, Mursi could be setting himself on a course for confrontation with liberal and other politicians and the judiciary.

"The decree is overturning a state where the rule of law reins. I advise you, Mr. President, to withdraw it because you swore to respect the law and the constitution," said Egyptian rights activist Hafez Abu Saeda, writing on Twitter.

"The president cancels the decision of the field marshal," wrote the daily Al Masry Al Youm, while Al Mal business daily carried the banner headline: "Back to your barracks."

The generals met late on Sunday to discuss Mursi's decree but did not release a statement. The Supreme Constitutional Court, which on June 14 ordered the lower house of parliament dissolved, said it would meet on Monday to review the move.

Farouk Soltan, who headed the court when it dismissed the parliament citing flaws in the election rules, said Mursi's decision had no legal basis. Soltan had administered the oath of office to Mursi on June 30, before his term on the court ended.

Though some officials in Mursi's Muslim Brotherhood had indicated that they interpreted the current, interim rules as giving the president the legal authority to recall parliament, analysts had expected the president to take a more cautious approach to avoid a head-on clash.

The military council has less formal room for maneuver now that it has transferred presidential powers to Mursi, so the public drama may play out in prolonged wrangling in the courts.

"I am not sure that power struggles played out in the legal sphere, and which add to the legal uncertainty of the past year and a half are healthy - either for us or the rule of law," said Heba Morayef of Human Rights Watch.

Mursi, however, is in a position unthinkable a year and half ago, when the Brotherhood was still banned and its members hounded by Mubarak - even if the army has stripped his presidency of some of the authority the office enjoyed under Mubarak, such as being supreme commander of the armed forces.

In one of his most high-profile meetings since taking office, Mursi met U.S. Deputy Secretary of State William Burns at the presidential palace on Sunday, signalling the new ties Washington is forging with resurgent Islamists in the region.

Burns pledged that the United States, which grants the Egyptian armed forces $1.3 billion a year in military aid, would support Egypt's economy, which has been hemorrhaging cash and is heading for a balance of payments and budget crisis.

Once a darling of emerging market fund managers, Egypt has watched foreign investors flee and its vital tourist trade has taken a big knock from the turmoil of the last year and a half.

Foreign reserves have plunged to about $15.5 billion, less than half their level before anti-Mubarak protests erupted, and the government has been forced to pay double-digit interest rates, seen as unsustainable, to fund its spending.

"Already domestic financing has reached a critical stage where you can't rely totally on the market any more," said one Western diplomat. The government was running up payment arrears with energy suppliers and raising funds from the central bank, the diplomat noted - tactics sustainable only for a short time.

Adding to the murky outlook that is unsettling investors, legal wrangling looks set to continue. Following the judges' dissolution of parliament and scrapping of a constitutional drafting panel appointed by parliament, further challenges in the courts could yet derail a second drafting panel.

As well as facing scrutiny by the Supreme Constitutional Court, Mursi's decision to recall parliament may also be challenged by rivals in the courts. Lawyer and liberal member of parliament Abul Ezz el-Hariry told Reuters he would file a suit on Monday. Hariry was a presidential candidate who fell out of the race in the first round.





Your feedback is important to us!

We invite all our readers to share with us their views and comments about this article.

Disclaimer: Comments submitted by third parties on this site are the sole responsibility of the individual(s) whose content is submitted. The Daily Star accepts no responsibility for the content of comment(s), including, without limitation, any error, omission or inaccuracy therein. Please note that your email address will NOT appear on the site.

Alert: If you are facing problems with posting comments, please note that you must verify your email with Disqus prior to posting a comment. follow this link to make sure your account meets the requirements. (

comments powered by Disqus



Interested in knowing more about this story?

Click here