Middle East

With Kerry on the way, Egypt liberals angry at U.S.

Egyptian pro-military supporters shout anti-Muslim Brotherhood slogans during a protest in Cairo.

CAIRO: As John Kerry heads to Egypt Saturday for his first visit as secretary of state, he faces a barrage of accusations from liberal and secular Egyptians who say Washington is siding with the ruling Muslim Brotherhood in the country’s sharp political divisions.

The United States has had its own frustrations with the mainly liberal and secular opposition, which has been plagued by disorganization and divisions. This week, it pressed the main opposition grouping, the National Salvation Front, to reverse its decision to boycott parliamentary elections due to begin in April.

Egypt has been locked in political crisis, amid successive waves of protests against Islamist President Mohammad Mursi that have repeatedly turned into deadly clashes and rioting.

The opposition accuses Mursi and the Brotherhood, from which he hails, of dominating power in Egypt, effectively stepping in to the same role as ousted autocrat Hosni Mubarak and failing to carry out reforms while their supporters seek to instill a more religiously conservative system. Mursi’s administration and the Brotherhood, in turn, say their opponents are trying to use street unrest to overturn their election victories.

Washington, Egypt’s longtime economic and military benefactor, has kept relatively warm ties with Mursi. The Obama administration has praised him for helping resolve last year’s battles between Israel and Hamas, the Islamic militant rulers of the Gaza Strip, and for maintaining Egypt’s peace treaty with Israel.

The U.S. has said it wants to encourage the building of democracy in Egypt and, amid the political turmoil, has urged all sides to work out their differences. But the opposition says U.S. officials have voiced little criticism of what it calls the Brotherhood’s undemocratic ways of imposing power, including pushing through an Islamist-backed constitution despite an opposition boycott at the end of its drafting.

At least two opposition figures said they rejected invitations to meet with Kerry when he holds talks with Egyptian political parties Saturday, ahead of the American diplomat’s meetings the next day with Mursi and the head of Egypt’s powerful military.

Ahmad al-Borai, a member of the National Salvation Front, was quoted in local newspapers saying that he rejected a U.S. Embassy’s invitation “so as to not allow a foreign party to dictate its will on Egyptians.”

Similarly, Egypt’s oldest opposition party, al-Wafd, said its chairman, al-Sayed al-Badawi, had also declined the embassy’s invitation to meet with Kerry.

Also not meeting with Kerry is Mohamed ElBaradei, one of the Salvation Front’s top leaders and perhaps the country’s most prominent opposition figure – though it is not clear if he was ever invited for a face-to-face.

The anti-Mursi camp’s anger with Kerry and the U.S. was on clear display Friday.

On its front page, the independent Al-Tahrir daily ran a large cartoon of Kerry, calling him “the Ikhwani” – or Brotherhood member – and depicting him with an Islamist’s beard and the “zibeeba,” a mark on the forehead many devout Muslim men have from kneeling in prayer five times a day. Also on display was the continued, angry polarization in the country’s politics.

The head of the Press Syndicate, Brotherhood member Mamdouh al-Wali, was mobbed by young journalists chanting “down with Brotherhood rule” as he left the syndicate headquarters during elections for a new chief of the union. The crowd shoved and jostled Wali, with one person slapping him on the back of the head, before he was hustled into his car.

Wali has been sharply criticized by other journalists for not taking legal action over the death of a young journalist during street battles between Brotherhood supporters and anti-Mursi opponents in December. He was also a member of the Islamist-dominated assembly that drafted the country’s new constitution but did not push for inclusion of articles to protect reporters from imprisonment as many in the media demand.

Several thousand backers of the army Friday also held a rally in a Cairo suburb calling on the powerful military to come back a take power, a sign of how a contingent in the anti-Mursi camp sees the generals as a possible protection against Islamist rule.

The State Department’s call on all political groups to participate in the upcoming parliamentary elections particularly angered many in the opposition, who saw Washington’s support for the election as backing for the Islamists themselves.

One opposition group, the National Association for Change, denounced the comments as “blatant interference in Egypt’s internal affairs.”

Hamdeen Sabahi, another senior figure in the Salvation Front, called on Kerry to be consistent in his comments about human rights and U.S. support of democracy.

In an interview with the Egyptian satellite channel ONTV late Thursday, Sabahi said Washington is only thinking of its interests in the region and accused the United States of striking a deal with the Brotherhood.

President Barack Obama spoke by phone this week with Mursi, emphasizing the Egyptian leader’s “responsibility to protect the democratic principles that the Egyptian people fought so hard to secure” and urged him and all political groups to find consensus, the White House said.

Obama also “welcomed Egypt’s continued role in advancing regional peace and maintaining the cease-fire in Gaza” – in what many in the anti-Mursi camp here see as a sign that the U.S. is more concerned with ensuring peace with Israel than with democracy in Egypt.

Bahey Eldin Hassan, of the Cairo Institute for Human Rights Studies, wrote an open letter to Obama earlier this month, saying that Washington should stop commenting on developments in Egypt. He said Washington’s comments give Mursi’s government “political cover.”

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Daily Star on March 02, 2013, on page 12.




Your feedback is important to us!

We invite all our readers to share with us their views and comments about this article.

Disclaimer: Comments submitted by third parties on this site are the sole responsibility of the individual(s) whose content is submitted. The Daily Star accepts no responsibility for the content of comment(s), including, without limitation, any error, omission or inaccuracy therein. Please note that your email address will NOT appear on the site.

Alert: If you are facing problems with posting comments, please note that you must verify your email with Disqus prior to posting a comment. follow this link to make sure your account meets the requirements. (

comments powered by Disqus



Interested in knowing more about this story?

Click here