Middle East

The reason behind Hamas’ mixed messages

Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, Emir of Qatar Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad al-Thani and exiled Hamas leader Khaled Meshaal meet in Doha August 21, 2014, in this photo provided by the Palestinian President Office.REUTERS/Thaer Ghanaim/ Palestinian President Office

OCCUPIED JERUSALEM/GAZA STRIP, Palestine: Founded by just seven people, Hamas now has political and military leaders spread across the Arab world, complicating its ability to send a unified message over the Gaza war.

In less than 30 years, what was a grassroots Islamic group has expanded well beyond the confines of Gaza.

But the Islamist movement’s diffuse structure and complex lines of communication have created confusion over whether it is responsible for staging some attacks on Israeli targets or not.

Illustrating this confusion, Hamas’ leader in the West Bank – who lives in exile in Turkey – claimed responsibility last week for the killing of three Jewish seminary students in June, an attack that led indirectly to this month’s conflict.

His claim was initially played down by others in Hamas, which had denied any involvement, before Hamas’ overall leader, Khaled Meshaal, accepted that it had carried out the killings.

“We were not aware of this action taken by this group of Hamas members in advance,” Meshaal, who lives in exile in Qatar, told Yahoo News, appearing reluctant to put any blame on the West Bank leadership for failing to notify him earlier.

“But we understand people are frustrated under the occupation and the oppression, and they take all kinds of actions,” he said.

“Hamas’ political leadership was not aware of all these details. We learned about it later on.”

Similar gaps in the movement’s position have emerged at other times, delaying negotiations on ending the conflict. An open-ended cease-fire to end the war was agreed by both sides Tuesday.

However, problems arose during initial rounds of talks, when Egyptian mediators, negotiating indirectly with Israel and the Palestinians in Cairo, struck a five-day cease-fire earlier this month.

Hamas negotiators then headed in different directions to consult on the way forward. Some went to Qatar to see Meshaal, others stayed in Cairo where the movement’s No. 2, Moussa Abu Marzouk, is based, and still others were due to return to Gaza.

Then, despite positive noises emerging about the possibility of an agreement, a spokesman for Hamas’ military wing dismissed the talks entirely. “The Palestinian delegation should leave Cairo immediately and not return,” declared Abu Ubaida, the spokesman for the Izz el-Deen al-Qassam Brigades. “Any move [towards a truce deal] will not be binding on us at all.”

Beverley Milton-Edwards, a professor of politics and international studies at Queen’s University in Belfast and a specialist on Hamas, has written about the difficulty of pinning the movement down on its positions.

“Hamas has a record of engaging in spoiler violence in order to have a negative impact on peace implementation,” she said, referring to earlier efforts to achieve peace with Israel.

Hamas, which stands for “Harakat al-Muqawama al-Islamiya” or the Islamic Resistance Movement, was founded by Sheikh Ahmed Yassin and six colleagues in December 1987.

An offshoot of the Muslim Brotherhood, it quickly gained popularity during the first Palestinian intifada. Its charter, published in 1988, calls for the destruction of Israel and the creation of an Islamic society in the whole of historic Palestine.

Hamas’ spread beyond Gaza was mostly a desire to unite with the Palestinian statehood cause in the occupied West Bank, but also partly due to Israel’s efforts to eradicate the movement.

After Yassin was assassinated in Gaza by an Israeli air strike in 2004 and his successor, Abdel-Aziz al-Rantissi, was also killed the same year, the baton passed to Meshaal, a political figure by then living in exile in Syria.

Meshaal, who survived an Israeli assassination attempt in the Jordanian capital Amman in 1997, fell out with Syria after Hamas criticized President Bashar Assad’s crackdown on opponents in the civil war, and moved to Qatar in 2012.

While he is recognized as the clear authority at the top of Hamas, and while the movement is disciplined, his inability to visit Gaza or the West Bank – he has been in exile for 37 years – means he is at times a distant figure. He also has a political rather than a military background.

Hamas has fought four conflicts with Israel since 2006, and its military wing has gained popularity among young Palestinian men, who have flocked to join its ranks. Hamas’ military chief, Mohammad Deif, has become almost a legendary figure, his reputation enhanced by his seldom appearing in public.

So popular is Deif, whose wife and two children were killed in an Israeli airstrike last week, that some Hamas watchers regard him as more powerful than Ismael Haniyeh, the former prime minister in Gaza and another Hamas leader.

The architect of the latest war, Deif is said to have no political ambitions, but his influence stretches beyond his official role and some analysts believe the military branch is eclipsing the political branch in some respects.

Meshaal, directing affairs from Doha, where he draws financial support from the Emir of Qatar, has tried to send the right signals. He met Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas last week and sought to present a united front in the negotiations.

Whether he can maintain that for all elements of Hamas – the political and military wings as well as leaders in Gaza, the West Bank, Cairo, Istanbul or elsewhere – remains to be seen.

“No one decides alone in Hamas. There is a vote and the majority rules,” said Hamza Abu Shanab, a Gaza analyst and an expert on Islamist factions. “The group may have begun small and in a tiny place ... but the [ultimate] decision remains that of the executive office.”

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Daily Star on August 27, 2014, on page 9.




Your feedback is important to us!

We invite all our readers to share with us their views and comments about this article.

Disclaimer: Comments submitted by third parties on this site are the sole responsibility of the individual(s) whose content is submitted. The Daily Star accepts no responsibility for the content of comment(s), including, without limitation, any error, omission or inaccuracy therein. Please note that your email address will NOT appear on the site.

Alert: If you are facing problems with posting comments, please note that you must verify your email with Disqus prior to posting a comment. follow this link to make sure your account meets the requirements. (

comments powered by Disqus



Interested in knowing more about this story?

Click here