Middle East

Leaked recording deepens divisions in Turks’ views of Erdogan

Supporters of Turkey's main opposition Republican People's Party (CHP) shout slogans against the government during a demonstration on February 26, 2014 on Istiklal Avenue in Istanbul. AFP PHOTO/OZAN KOSE

ISTANBUL/ANKARA: Turks in the conservative Istanbul district where Recep Tayyip Erdogan grew up stood defiantly by their prime minister Wednesday in the face of a voice recording purportedly of him warning his son to hide large sums of money.

The mood contrasted sharply with one of outrage in areas where Erdogan enjoys less support, illustrating the deepening polarization of a country that his AK Party has ruled since 2002, presiding over a decade of growing prosperity.

Opposition politicians called on Erdogan to resign over the audiotape, but he has stood firm, accusing enemies of hacking encrypted state communications to fake a phone call at the time of police raids into a graft inquiry.

“I think this investigation is an effort to remove Erdogan from power by enemies of Turkey. He has made our country stronger, richer, with a say in the world,” said clothing shop owner Belguzar Ekmen, 33, who thinks the recordings are fake.

“I can’t say whether there has been corruption, but I can measure how much our lives have improved, in terms of health care, education, transportation,” he said in the working class Kasimpasa district on Istanbul’s Golden Horn waterway.

Before Erdogan came to power, Turkey was plagued by chronic high inflation and economic crises under unstable coalition governments.

The recording, which triggered furious mutual recriminations between political parties in parliament Tuesday, dominated media coverage that reflected the deep divisions between the pro- and anti-Erdogan camps.

“A shameless montage,” said headlines in the pro-government Yeni Safak and Sabah newspapers, echoing Erdogan’s condemnation of recordings which he made clear he blamed on a network run by a former ally, preacher Fethullah Gulen.

“The recording which is shaking Turkey,” a headline in the liberal Radikal daily said. “Flee or resign,” the secularist Cumhuriyet said, quoting the main opposition leader.

The recording purports to be of Erdogan and his son Bilal discussing how to reduce funds at home to “zero” by distributing them among several businessmen. At one point, the voice supposedly of Bilal says some 30 million euros ($40 million) still remained to be disposed of.

The left-wing BirGun daily printed a transcript of the five recordings over its entire front page without naming Erdogan or Bilal, describing them as a “father” and “son.”

“We have never been so corrupt, so rotten. Can you imagine? The prime minister and his family have so much money they don’t know where to put it,” said company manager Elif, 32, smoking outside a cafe in an upmarket Ankara district.

“I believe the tapes are true. I have always thought that he was stealing,” said Hasan Demir, 37, an Ankara cab driver. “But I know people will vote for him again. They distribute coal, rice to poor people. Who can say no to that?”

Gulen, through his lawyer, has described the accusation of complicity in the tapes as unjust and contributing to an atmosphere of “hatred and enmity” in Turkish society.

Opinion polls conducted before the recordings surfaced indicate Erdogan’s popularity has held up despite the corruption scandal that broke on Dec. 17 with the detention of businessmen close to him and three ministers’ sons.

Support for Erdogan is robust in Kasimpasa, with giant posters bearing his image plastered over facades of buildings. At Erdinc Guner’s barbershop, a small group of men, smoking and drinking tea in between haircuts and shaves, all back Erdogan’s AK Party.

“He has made up for any corruption with what he has done in services for the people,” said Guner, 27. “This country has known far worse in the past. Besides, who else is there to vote for? The AKP’s greatest advantage is the sorry state of the opposition.”

But the latest recordings may provide a stiffer test of how his support is maintained ahead of March 30 local elections.

Rising political tension has hit Turkish financial markets, but the lira and shares were firmer Wednesday. 

The recording have also triggered street protests, but on a much smaller scale than anti-government demonstrations last summer.

Police used tear gas to disperse protesters in the capital Ankara Wednesday, while in Istanbul demonstrators gathered on central Taksim Square.

Erdogan accuses Gulen of building a “parallel state” using influence in the judiciary and police and has hit back at the corruption probe by reassigning thousands of police officers and hundreds of judges and prosecutors. 

He has also pushed through parliament laws tightening control of the judiciary and Internet. The assembly approved adjustments to the Internet law overnight, addressing President Abdullah Gul’s concerns about the tighter restrictions.

Gul Wednesday approved the judiciary law, deferring to the Constitutional Court on some elements in the legislation that the main opposition CHP has vowed to challenge in the court. 

The law will give the government more say in the naming of judges and prosecutors, a role currently fulfilled by the High Council of Judges and Prosecutors (HSYK). 

Critics say the move contravenes the basic principle of the separation of powers enshrined in the constitution.

“The HSYK has been perceived by the government as the headquarters of this so-called parallel structure, so with this law the government is dissolving that center,” the president of the Association of Judges and Prosecutors, Murat Arslan, said.

“It is a major blow to the independence of the judiciary. We were not a defender of the old HSYK law but this one is even worse.” 





Your feedback is important to us!

We invite all our readers to share with us their views and comments about this article.

Disclaimer: Comments submitted by third parties on this site are the sole responsibility of the individual(s) whose content is submitted. The Daily Star accepts no responsibility for the content of comment(s), including, without limitation, any error, omission or inaccuracy therein. Please note that your email address will NOT appear on the site.

Alert: If you are facing problems with posting comments, please note that you must verify your email with Disqus prior to posting a comment. follow this link to make sure your account meets the requirements. (

comments powered by Disqus



Interested in knowing more about this story?

Click here