Mobile  |  About us  |  Photos  |  Videos  |  Subscriptions  |  RSS Feeds  |  Today's Paper  |  Classifieds  |  Contact Us
The Daily Star
SATURDAY, 26 MAY 2012
08:08 PM Beirut time
Weather    
Beirut
22 °C
Blom Index
1,164.1up
A+ A-
     
 
Advanced Search
Commentary  
Probe U.N. neglect in South Kordofan

The United Nations, already examining the performance of its peacekeeping troops in Abyei in May, must widen its investigations to their performance in the Nuba Mountains region of South Kordofan in June. In Abyei, Zambian peacekeepers stand accused of staying in their barracks during fighting between government forces and the Sudan People’s Liberation Army (SPLA). In South Kordofan, Egyptian troops are accused of actively conspiring with government forces against the Nuba SPLA – for the last several years the government’s partner in peace, but denounced by Khartoum as a “rebel group” ever since fighting erupted a month ago.

I had decided, on balance, not to write this piece. I felt it was not the moment to focus on the peacekeepers, outgunned in the new fighting and under orders from Khartoum to leave South Kordofan by July 9. More important, for the moment, surely, are the disproportionate attacks on Nuba civilians – especially aerial attacks. With some activists already taking a leaf out of the book of the Save Darfur movement, crying “genocide” and “extermination” instead of building a rigorous, fact-based case, there aren’t enough hours in the day to get the evidence needed to prove that June saw, at the very least, systematic ethnic targeting of black African Nuba in the now-difficult-to-access Nuba mountains.

What changed my mind? An image. Not of women and children torn apart by 500-pound bombs. Of peacekeepers – taking photographs of protesters in Kauda, a Nuba town attacked by Antonovs and MIG-29s eight times in June. There they are, with their digital cameras, snapping away as Nuba women rail against their “inaction” and “collaboration and connivance” with Khartoum.

It wasn’t, admittedly, as bad as Tawila in North Darfur in May 2008, when U.N. troops stood in little huddles, comparing photographs, as Janjaweed ran amok under their noses. But two days before U.N. troops treated the Kauda protest as something anecdotal, another snap for a triumphal album, a single government bomb killed and wounded dozens of civilians in Kurchi village. Photos taken by the Nuba are not family viewing – two little girls spooned in death, with a red plastic jug suggesting they were on their way to, or perhaps from, Kurchi’s water point when it was hit; a third, her abdomen a crimson flower; a fourth, cradled bloodily in a young man’s arms.

No U.N. troops took photos in Kurchi. At the time of writing they had not been to the village.

The U.N. peacekeeping mission UNMIS has been a part of the problem in South Kordofan, where many Nuba, although northern Sudanese, joined south Sudan’s war for a democratic “New Sudan.” Established in March 2005, after the Comprehensive Peace Agreement ended the 22-year civil war, the mission was headed until 2010 by a man who colleagues say was given to calling the Nuba “monkeys.” On his watch, the lack of initiative of UNMIS and perceived complicity with Khartoum was a cause of deep frustration, and anger, to its most committed staff. UNMIS was also spectacularly uninformed about the reality of South Kordofan.

In 2008, I published a report that detailed the resurgence of government-supported militias in South Kordofan – including in a village called Al-Fayd – and concluded that “many now view war in the Nuba Mountains as inevitable.” UNMIS pooh-poohed the report, which it said was “far from the reality on the ground.” Fast-forward to April this year, on the eve of war, and an attack by militia who, according to UNMIS, “killed … looted … burnt houses and raped.” The village? Al-Fayd.

How little UNMIS knew. How little it cared to know! And how it has come to haunt the mission now that its own men are, in its own words, facing increasing “intimidation and obstruction” in South Kordofan – including from the militias it said did not exist.

As a neighbor of Sudan, Egypt was expected put its bilateral relations ahead of its peacekeeping duties. However, the extent of the Egyptians’ bias has shocked even senior staff from UNMIS.

Says one former staffer: “All political interpretations of the situation came straight from the Khartoum regime and were disseminated by the Egyptian army as UNMIS position both to the local parties and the population at large. The racism that the Khartoum regime displayed openly toward the opposition SPLM the Egyptians repeated consistently and without variation.”

Another: “On many occasions when the Egyptians wanted to go someplace that was strictly forbidden to all military, they would go to the National Intelligence and Security Service, or to the army’s division commander, and after a 15-minute meeting would have clearance that was unavailable to all other military components in UNMIS. Afterward they would not report on their mission and would ignore all requests for information. Many suspected that they were actually working with the Khartoum regime while on these strange sorties.”

UNMIS is now under improved leadership in South Kordofan. But the Egyptian forces are a power unto themselves. Early in the June war, they refused to help evacuate international relief workers from Kadugli, the state capital. Without Egyptian armored personnel carriers, the Westerners had to be moved in soft-skinned vehicles. Nuba allege that the APCs were put to use barely a week later – transporting militia and the Central Reserve Police, a military force in all but name and involved in gross human rights abuses in Kadugli.

The many charges leveled against UNMIS may not all be true, but they form part of a pattern of bias and neglect that requires serious investigation and complete transparency. A starting point could be the question asked by the Nuba commander, Abdel Aziz al-Hilu, in a letter to his Egyptian counterpart three days before war began.

“We have noticed,” he wrote, “that the forces of the Central Reserve Police have chosen as their camp an area adjacent to the headquarters of your forces. The type of weapons and vehicles used by these forces indicate they are combat troops. Our question is: What is the relation between your forces and these?”

Julie Flint writes frequently about Sudan for THE DAILY STAR. Her report, “The Drift Back to War,” is available at www.smallarmssurveysudan.org/pdfs/HSBA-SIB-12-drift-back-to-war.pdf.

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Daily Star on July 05, 2011, on page 7.
Home Commentary
 
 
Advertisement
Comments  
Ibrahim Adam July 06, 2011 05:13 PM

Typical hubris from ‘Nuba Julie’ about Sudan, complete with standard journo-activists brickbats thrown at ‘Khartoum’.

Moreover, it’s especially strange that Nuba J should choose to deliver her standard, fossilised sermon about the Nuba people now and seek to internationalise this relatively small spat; a peace agreement got inked just over a week ago to address the key underlying political issue that sparked the fighting in SK, namely:

The SPLM in South Kordofan and the rest of (non-south) Sudan has been left as a body without a head following the southern referendum: southern Sudanese members of the SPLM performed a right-angled turn away from the unity ‘New Sudan’ philosophy of the late Dr. John Garang in favour of the hasty rush to separation of South Sudan, leaving Abdul-Aziz Al-Hilu ( a veteran Nuba SPLA commander-turned deputy governor of S K who, diva-like, launched the violence there following the Carter Center-endorsed victories of the NCP in USAID-supported gubernatorial and state legislative elections) and other leading lights of the SPLM Northern Sector rudderless, demoralised, and fearful for their own political survival, going forward.

That ‘betrayal’, no question, is what rankles most with Abdul-Aziz Hilu and his Hiluites in the Nuba Mountains. Southern Sudanese evidently didn’t care enough about the Nuba (or the Ingesanna of Blue Nile State), in spite of their many sacrifices that made the very option of a self-determination referendum for southern Sudan possible; see SPLM Blue Nile Governor Malik Agar’s recent description in the NYT of a “cornered cat” as illustrative. (A kitten cast out from the rest of its litter would be a more appropriate analogy of the crisis of direction facing the SPLM’s Northern sector ahead of the south’s separation).

Nuba J: please note, too, that it was the SPLA that started the fighting in SK – not the PDF or another ‘Khartoum’ militia that you had bleated on about as likely ‘firestarters’ there.

Khaled Ibrahim July 07, 2011 08:09 PM

Julie,

I am feeling ashamed to say I am Egyptian to my fellows from Nuba... But no wonder Ms Julie, the Egyptian Commander in Southern Kordofan belongs the the same institution that is halting the reforms in Egypt since the departure of Mubarak..
One fugitive told me today that the Sudanese Armed Forces has repeated exactly the same atrocities of the Israeli Army. Getting a faked list of insurgents, looting the houses, shoot to kill and tearing down the houses. He told me that what happened is unforgettable and it will stay in the heart and mind of Nuba people and the day will come to retaliate.

Your feedback is important to us!
We invite all our readers to share with us their views and comments about this article.

Disclaimer: Comments submitted by third parties on this site are the sole responsibility of the individual(s) whose content is submitted. The Daily Star accepts no responsibility for the content of comment(s), including, without limitation, any error, omission or inaccuracy therein. Please note that your email address will NOT appear on the site. All fields are mandatory.

Name *
Email *
Country *
City *
Comment
*
Word Count: Left:
Toolbox
print
email
e-paper
e-paper
More from
Julie Flint
The Nuba Mountains war isn’t going away
War clouds gather in South Kordofan
Spare a thought for the other Sudanese
Sudan's election boycott: the underside
Back to bloody square-one in Darfur
Bashir is guilty, but does Sudan benefit?
Darfur has gone regional, and the UN is useless
Giving a voice to the forgotten Arab victims of Darfur
Talking about Lebanon with Bobby Fischer
A seismic political shift is taking place in Darfur
View allview all
Advertisement
Most Popular
Viewed Searched e-mailed
1. Lebanese abducted in Syria free in Turkey, waiting to come home
 
2. Hezbollah says for unconditional dialogue, thanks Hariri for hostage release efforts
 
3. Syria grain trade signals alarm for Assad
 
4. In a first, U.S. declares 5 million Palestinians to be refugees: report
 
5. Over 90 killed in Syria massacre: activists
 
6. Lebanon accuses Israel of Shebaa Farms violation
Advertisement
 
Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Linked In Follow us on Google+ Subscribe to our Live Feed
 
Multimedia
Images Video  
Pictures of the Day
A selection of images from around the world- Thursday May 24, 2012
View all view all
Rami G. Khouri
Rami G. Khouri
Egyptians as they really are, for once
Michael Young
Michael Young
Will Tripoli make Samir Geagea pay?
David Ignatius
David Ignatius
A string of detonators cuts through the Middle East
View all view all
 
cartoon
 
Click to View Articles
Advertisement
 
 
News
Business
Opinion
Sports
Culture
Technology
Entertainment
Privacy Policy | Anti-Spamming Policy | Disclaimer | Copyright Notice
© 2011 The Daily Star - All Rights Reserved - Designed and Developed By IDS