Mursi could emerge as the new pharaoh

On Dec. 15 and Dec. 22, Egypt’s draft Constitution is due to be put to a referendum. A year ago, Egyptians were thrilled to know that finally their country’s constitution would reflect their democratic hopes and aspirations. Yet the document that they will now vote on is more likely to dash those hopes and dim the prospects for democracy for Egyptians.The constitutional drafting process was rushed through, without the input of liberals, non-Muslims and women, all of whom boycotted the process, owing to the preponderance of Islamists. The Muslim Brotherhood, and primarily President Mohammad Mursi, is banking on the assumption that the strength of Egypt’s Islamist vote will earn him enough support among “regular Egyptians,” and that the opposition will have little impact on the outcome of the referendum.

One political adviser of the ruling Freedom and Justice Party – which is the Muslim Brotherhood’s political wing – even boasted that the hood could easily mobilize 20 million supporters. The Brotherhood dismisses those who have demonstrated in the streets during the past three weeks as sympathizers of the former president, Hosni Mubarak.

Mursi’s decision on Nov. 22 to grant himself absolute authority for the spurious purpose of defending the revolution is not new when it comes to Egypt. A succession of dictator-presidents has ruled the country under a state of emergency for more than 40 years. While Mursi has now bowed to pressure to annul a decree granting him powers without judicial oversight, it seems only yesterday that people were prepared to put their fears aside and trust that Mursi was ready to rule in the interests of all Egyptians.

Eric Trager of the Washington Institute for Near East Policy notes that Mursi’s previous role in the Muslim Brotherhood’s Guidance Council sheds some light on the motives behind his current behavior. In the past, Mursi advocated a platform that excluded Christians from political life and granted Islamic scholars oversight authority to ensure that all legislation complied with Shariah, or Islamic law. He also worked to expunge young members of the Freedom and Justice Party that he deemed to hold dissenting views.

While the draft constitution does contain positive provisions, others are causing concern. Article 11 authorizes the state to “safeguard ethics, public morality, and public order, and foster a high level of education and of religious and patriotic values.” This leaves plenty of room for interpretation by the government. In addition, the mosque of Al-Azhar is promised an advisory role in Islamic legislation.

The political opponents of the Muslim Brotherhood have not been silent. On Dec. 8, the National Salvation Front announced that the draft “does not represent the Egyptian people.” Moreover, ordinary Egyptians have responded viscerally and swiftly to Mursi’s moves, perhaps more so than the president had anticipated. Strikes were organized, newspapers halted publication, and fears of widespread insurrection remain high. Hundreds have been injured in street clashes in Cairo. The president’s supporters have declared that “defending Mursi is defending Islam.”

Today, Mursi seems as besieged as Syria’s President Bashar Assad. The military has barricaded the presidential palace and, until the results of the referendum are announced, the armed forces are under orders to protect Egypt’s state institutions.

Outside the Middle East, the United States has scaled back its relations with Egypt since the government’s weak response to the attack on the U.S. Embassy in September. This has signaled a rapid deterioration in bilateral relations. America’s main priority now is to ensure that the peace treaty with Israel is maintained.

The European Union cannot afford to engage in wishful thinking when it comes to Mursi’s ambitions and the Muslim Brotherhood’s agenda. The EU’s “more for more” policy has made human rights a cornerstone of its foreign policy toward the states in the European neighborhood. And though Mursi’s recent role in mediating discussions between Hamas and the Israeli government was invaluable in preventing a serious regional conflict, his government’s actions are undermining prospects for further cooperation with Europe.

No matter how Mursi attempts to sideline his domestic opponents, Egypt today is in no shape to ignore the rest of the world. It lacks a stable economy, relying heavily on tourism and imports to feed the country’s more than 80 million people. Power cuts and public-service strikes are a regular feature of daily life.

Egypt’s government needs to secure consistent foreign financing to keep the country afloat. This has provided leverage for international opposition to Mursi’s efforts to impose an agenda that runs contrary to the fundamental rights of Egyptians. Egypt can thrive only on the basis of honest adherence to a democratic process.

The current constitutional crisis has caused many to wonder how Egypt will face future political tests. The outcome of the referendum will prove an important guide regarding the direction the country is likely to take. Will it embrace a new Islamic authoritarianism, or build the democracy that Egyptians have risked their lives to secure?

Fiorello Provera is vice chair of the Foreign Affairs Committee in the European Parliament. THE DAILY STAR publishes this commentary in collaboration with Project Syndicate © (

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Daily Star on December 14, 2012, on page 7.




Your feedback is important to us!

We invite all our readers to share with us their views and comments about this article.

Disclaimer: Comments submitted by third parties on this site are the sole responsibility of the individual(s) whose content is submitted. The Daily Star accepts no responsibility for the content of comment(s), including, without limitation, any error, omission or inaccuracy therein. Please note that your email address will NOT appear on the site.

Alert: If you are facing problems with posting comments, please note that you must verify your email with Disqus prior to posting a comment. follow this link to make sure your account meets the requirements. (

comments powered by Disqus



Interested in knowing more about this story?

Click here