Middle East

Iraqi Shiite volunteers: More hindrance than help?

BAGHDAD: The Iraqi soldier says he abandoned the army last week in despair. And while he still plans to fight he will not rejoin the unit he deserted in the city of Ramadi.

Instead, he wants to sign up as a volunteer, alongside tens of thousands of others, to help defend Shiite shrines against Sunni insurgents who have swept the country’s north and west and who he believes now threaten his sect.

“The officers brought us to the point where a soldier could either die or flee,” the 31-year-old said, asking his name be withheld to avoid punishment.

“I’ll go fight as a volunteer. I won’t go as a soldier. I’m not afraid,” he said. “I have my faith.”

The deserter’s story illustrates a dynamic increasingly shaping a conflict that could tear Iraq apart: With the army’s northern divisions hard hit by desertions as key Sunni cities fell in June, Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki’s Shiite-led government has leaned heavily on Shiite militias and volunteers motivated by a sense of religious duty.

In some areas, there are now at least as many Shiite gunmen and civilian volunteers as there are regular soldiers and volunteers, a militia spokesman said. Some go to the front, while others man checkpoints, guard bases and carry out raids.

“The end result is it is not an improvement in political stability,” said Anthony Cordesman of the Center for Strategic and International Studies. “And it is certainly not an improvement in building a bridge between Sunnis and Shiites.”

Volunteers in desert camouflage salute as they enter Colonel Ali al-Majidi’s office, a spacious room packed with ornate sofas, coffee tables, ashtrays and vases at a military base in the Abu Ghraib district west of Baghdad.

He said 1,200 volunteers have arrived to bolster his original force of over 3,400 troops since Grand Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani, Iraq’s most influential Shiite preacher, called on all men able to carry arms to fight the insurgency June 13.

Their arrival has provided vital relief for Majidi’s men, who oversee an area bordering Anbar, where insurgents control the two largest cities.

The volunteers were mostly given “second line” duties such as searching cars and manning checkpoints, the colonel said, although a few were so eager they pushed ahead to the front lines on their own. “If they’re trained and they want to join their brothers, we will not say no,” he said.

Sistani’s fatwa has ensured there is no shortage of such volunteers, many of them young men from poor Shiite areas who see volunteering as a solemn obligation.

More are signing up every day. Hundreds of sweat-stained men trudged across a dirt lot strewn with cardboard and plastic bottles in baking heat to register at a training camp in the northern Baghdad neighborhood of Sadr Kanat this week.

Inside, recruits crammed on to stained bunk beds in dark rooms decorated incongruously with images of flowers and waterfalls. Dozing in the midday heat, the men jumped to attention when an officer barked for them to present themselves to a visiting journalist.

No one hesitated when asked why he signed up. “The preacher’s call,” said one. “To defend the nation,” said a second. “To defend Iraq.”

Most volunteers interviewed for this article were unquestionably enthusiastic, but even some Iraqi officials question how effective their deployment will ultimately be.

One 25-year-old fighter in Samarra, near the front line, said many new arrivals were too young or poorly trained to be useful.

One accidentally shot a comrade while riding behind him in a car, the fighter said. Another shot himself dead while holding his rifle between his legs without turning the safety on.

“It was a mistake for the government to send them,” the man said over the phone from Samarra, asking not to be identified so he could speak openly. “Your fighters need to be ready or you will not be able to confront an organized enemy.”

He said his own unit of over 700 fighters had come under fire after rerouting from Anbar to Samarra last month, and more than two-thirds deserted. Much of the ammunition they were given was poor quality, and water was sometimes so scarce some people drank from the river, he said.

Cordesman said the usefulness of the volunteers was also limited by the number of quality instructors available.

“Untrained young men are going to be enthusiastic in combat for about six minutes on the outside,” he said.

An official in the prime minister’s office, who asked to remain unidentified, said volunteers who were not trained enough to fight hardened insurgents like ISIS were not being put at risk.

“What I can say is that the government is taking the lives of these volunteers very seriously. These people are volunteering to defend Iraq rather than to just be sent out to their deaths,” he said.

The relative prowess of Shiite militias has helped the army slow the militants’ advance and stabilize the battle lines.

Iranian-backed groups Asaib Ahl al-Haq and Kataib Hezbollah, who have been fighting alongside government forces around western Anbar and Baghdad’s perimeter since winter, have become increasingly visible since Mosul fell to militants June 10, setting off the Iraqi forces’ collapse.

Asaib spokesman Ahmad al-Kinani said the group’s forces had been active in the eastern Diyala province, areas around Samarra and in the western and southern outskirts of Baghdad. He declined to specify how many fighters were operating, but said it was “thousands.”

“We can say it’s an equal percentage. It doesn’t matter if there are 50 from here and 100 from here. The most important thing is the goal,” he said.

Followers of Shiite preacher Moqtada al-Sadr, who fought United States troops under the banner of the Mahdi Army during the 2003-11 occupation, have returned as “Peace Brigades.”

A Shiite lawmaker in Maliki’s State of Law list admitted deployment of the militias had been “chaotic” in the first week after Mosul’s fall when some carried out vigilante slayings in Baghdad, dumping bodies on the streets in an echo of the sectarian bloodshed that convulsed Iraq in 2006 and 2007.

“There were a lot of assassinations and killing. They were taking the law in their own hand,” he said. But “unaccountable” militias had now been brought under control, he added, and armed groups were helping to secure the capital and improving the army’s morale.

He credited them with filling gaps on Baghdad’s southern boundaries where security forces had been absent. “Some of the militias are very good fighters,” he added. “They are motivated and some of them are ready to die. When you think like this, you can face up to ISIS.”

Sistani, apparently wary of empowering the militias and fueling sectarianism, has called for volunteers to stay within “the framework of the state” and has repeatedly stressed his initial fatwa applied to all Iraqis, not just Shiites.

Yet there is rarely much effort made to conceal Shiite domination of the process. Across Baghdad, images of Shiite saints adorn many checkpoints. At the training base in the capital’s north, a banner of a slain fighter from a Shiiite militia hangs near the door where volunteers gather to register. Shiite preachers pace the halls inside, some in army fatigues.

Sunni communities have been shaken by the combination of volunteers and militias fanning out with the security forces.

Last weekend, a group of elite Interior Ministry forces and militiamen entered a rural Sunni area south of Baghdad in four-wheel drives and Humvees and detained 17 men after Friday prayers, a relative of one of the detainees said. Four were released after five days. The others are still being held.

“They take them to an unknown place. They don’t show any arrest orders,” said the family member, speaking on condition of anonymity.

Shiiite communities have paid a heavy toll as well. One man who washes bodies before burial in the Shiite holy city of Najaf said he had seen at least 20 volunteers buried since Sistani’s call to arms.

One of the dead, Anwar Jassem Ouda, was shot in the eye as he fought around the insurgent-held town of Garma in Anbar.

His mother wept as she held his body and kissed his face. “My son,” she said. “I have raised you all these years to die.”

A version of this article appeared in the print edition of The Daily Star on July 11, 2014, on page 8.




Your feedback is important to us!

We invite all our readers to share with us their views and comments about this article.

Disclaimer: Comments submitted by third parties on this site are the sole responsibility of the individual(s) whose content is submitted. The Daily Star accepts no responsibility for the content of comment(s), including, without limitation, any error, omission or inaccuracy therein. Please note that your email address will NOT appear on the site.

Alert: If you are facing problems with posting comments, please note that you must verify your email with Disqus prior to posting a comment. follow this link to make sure your account meets the requirements. (http://bit.ly/vDisqus)

comments powered by Disqus



Interested in knowing more about this story?

Click here